cura impotenza sildenafil rezeptfrei aquisto levitra cialis moins cher kamagra gel acquisto viagra originale achat vardenafil viagra vendita on line levitra precio prix de cialis acquisto viagra viagra kopen cialis ordonnance acheter tadalafil kamagra generique acheter cialis internet comprar levitra cialis venta viagra en ligne cialis donne tadalafil venta viagra senza ricetta tadalafil generique achat de viagra medicament impuissance impuissance homme pastilla viagra tadalafil precio levitra naturale cialis sin receta commande levitra achete levitra cialis 20 mg sildenafil kaufen achat pharmacie acheter cialis sur la net viagra ordonnance cialis bon prix levitra en ligne impuissance sexuelle generische levitra levitra generico achat cialis 20mg acheter cialis generique acheter isotretinoine achat de levitra viagra versand cialis en pharmacie viagra controindicazioni achat kamagra viagra 50 mg koop viagra viagra sans prescription cialis sans ordonnance comprar viagra pela internet kamagra 100 viagra suisse viagra indien viagra kosten sildenafil moins cher vente cialis propecia prix zyban generique acheter cialis en ligne kamagra te koop cialis preço kamagra rezeptfrei viagra ricetta cialis effetti collaterali compro levitra levitra prijs acquisto viagra on line cialis generico sicuro cialis prijs acheter levitra pas chere cialis suisse acheter clomid en france cialis ohne rezept impotenza cure levitra effet secondaire viagra europe aquisto cialis commander du cialis levitra senza ricetta cialis prix vendo levitra prozac prix cialis kauf procurer du levitra cialis generique acheter commander kamagra acheter cialis en belgique viagra naturel acquisto viagra net generique cialis pastilla sildenafil acquisto viagra senza ricetta citrato di sildenafil comprar vardenafil sildenafil venta levitra donna viagra vendita italia achat cialis generique vardenafil generika sildenafil generico vardenafil bestellen sildenafil 50 mg propecia moins cher procurer du viagra acheter cialis en espagne vendita levitra compra viagra comprar sildenafil acheter kamagra 100mg levitra donne viagra alternativo zithromax generique vardenafil generique procurer du cialis pastilla cialis il viagra vendita cialis viagra ricetta medica levitra a vendre tadalafil 10 mg comprar cialis em portugal vardenafil 10 mg ordina viagra levitra generico viagra sin receta compro viagra acheter cialis
Sep
07
2008

Current Headline News Useful for Freshman College Science Courses

As I’ve mentioned before, I am currently teaching an intro level biology course for freshman non-majors. At the moment we’re still talking about the nature of science, specifically focusing on junk science and common misconceptions and misrepresentations of science in the media and in public opinion.

One of the things I’m using is a clip of an old John Stossell report called “Junk Science: What you know that may not be so“. Two examples are presented in this clip. In the first, it presents the old “breast plants caused my connective tissue disease” explosion that occurred in the last decade. Basically, a bunch of people got sick after getting breast implants and they attributed it to the implants themselves. In reality, after many many studies, we learned that the incidence of disease in people with breast plants is identical to those without them.

In a second clip, a similar thing happened with dioxin exposure. Essentially, we now know that these exposures had no effects on humans.

Both of these examples present clear cases of the phenomenon of fallacious logic referred to as “post hoc ergo propter hoc”, which means “after this, therefore because of it”. People got sick after the events (implants or dioxin) and attributed the incidents as the cause, mistaking a (coincidental) correlation with causation.

Both clips also show quite well how media, lawyers, fear, ignorance, and politics all have their own hands in the promotion of junk science.

In an excellent piece of news from this Friday’s reports on LiveScience.com, written by Benjamin Radford, yet another study, this one considered large and definitive, has shown that there is no link between childhood MMR vaccines and autism. Most of the science community has known this for years, but as with many other examples, fear trumps sound logic and many still cling to this fear.

Excerpt:

Many parents came to believe that vaccines caused their children’s autism because the symptoms of autism appeared after the child received a vaccination. On a psychological level, that assumption and connection makes sense; but on a logical level, it is a clear and common fallacy with a fancy Latin name: post hoc ergo propter hoc (”after this, therefore because of it”).

Because the human mind seeks connections, people often misattribute causes, thinking that, “B happened after A did, so A must have caused B.” The child was fine until he was vaccinated, and soon he showed signs of autism. It makes sense–except that it’s not necessarily true. It’s like saying “roosters crow before the sun rises, so the roosters must have made the sun rise.”

The article presents the mistake of using individual correlations to attribute vaccinations to autism in an easily understandable way, and would make an excellent VERY short reading for any intro level science course. I like to send a steady stream of easily digestible current biological news bits to my students, especially for non-science majors. It’s so much easier to keep their attention and to make them see why they should care when you can weave currently reported debates into the lesson. So if any of you are teaching such a course, I highly recommend this article for both its relevance to our lives and to understanding how misuse of “evidence” can lead to unnecessary fears and “pseudoscience”.


Written by Irradiatus in
Categories: Biology, Education, Pseudoscience, Science, Science Outreach, Skepticism
Tags: , , , , ,

9 Comments »

  • [...] own post on using current (and old) news to teach the difference between science and pseudoscience and the post hoc ergo propter hoc [...]

  • [...] of science in the media and in public opinion, courtesy of Irradiatus who presents Current Headline News Useful for Freshman College Science Courses posted at [...]

  • Kobra says:

    I really wish middle and high school educators would focus on the difference between real science and junk science. (I also wish they would focus on critical thinking skills.)

    However, what you’re doing is sure to make an impact. I commend you for your valiant efforts in the war against pseudoscience. :D

  • Irradiatus says:

    I completely agree.
    It seems to me that this sort of strategy should be one of the primary methods used to teach science during primary school (at least during the course intro materials).

    Obviously, some basic memorization is necessary in understanding science and its terminology. But I personally think that the underlying critical thinking skills are a thousand times more important to impart to those young developing brains.

    But no – No Child Left Behind says they must be taught to take multiple choice tests. Who cares if they’re actually thinking. And I can tell you first hand that the effects of the NCLB method are already apparent in the current freshman college students.

    Thanks for the comment!

  • [...] have included my own recent post on using the new Vaccine/Autism study, which further confirms the LACK of any connection whatsoever [...]

  • Don says:

    So, do you teach your students that dioxin is not toxic?

  • Irradiatus says:

    No, of course not. The specific toxicity of dioxin is not the purpose of the exercise. What we talk about is the specific evidence used by the two towns (Sevesso, Italy and Times Beach, Missouri) and how they used or disregarded that evidence. At the time, animal models showed toxicity, while plenty of human exposure studies had shown no problems.

    However, perhaps you know that “dioxin” does not refer to a single compound. Some “dioxins” have little to no toxicity while others have specific toxicities.

    In fact the word refers to two completely different types of compounds. In common usage, “dioxins” refers to polychlorinated dibenzodioxins, while “dioxin” can refer to dibenzofuran.

    Different chemicals, different toxicities.

    But again, in the class we barely focus at all on the specific compounds. This is an intro class for non-science majors, and it was also an introductory lecture to the class in which we simply talk about the nature of science, the nature of evidence, and the fallacy of using individual anecdotal correlations.

    I hope that answers your question.

  • Anissa says:

    just came across. Nice blog

  • acne myths says:

    Substantially, the article is really the greatest topic on curing acne naturally. I concur with your conclusions and will eagerly look forward to your forthcoming updates. Just saying thanks will not just be adequate, for the phenomenal lucidity in your writing. I will directly grab your rss feed to stay abreast of any updates.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL


Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>


If you want your own image displayed - go get your "globally recognized avatar" at gravatar.com.

Powered by WordPress | Theme: Aeros 2.0 by TheBuckmaker.com

  • cheap online pharmacies
  • all natural sleep aid
  • natural supplements for mens health
  • celebrex celebrex
  • drug free high blood pressure help
  • medications without prescription
  • drug stores
  • drug lipitor
  • stress reliever
  • overdose zolpidem
  • atacand generic
  • mirtazapine depression
  • pet safe products
  • dog and cat care
  • weight loss program
  • weight loss health health
  • levaquin urinary
  • online pharmacy and online prescription
  • anti allergic drug
  • social anxiety
  • over the counter drugs
  • cheap cialis online
  • weight loss pills
  • buy pain medicine on-line
  • lisinopril online
  • cheap alcoholism treatment
  • paxil for depression
  • buy super cialis
  • natural muscle and joint health
  • top acne treatments
  • nexium effects
  • hypertension
  • buy erectile dysfunction online
  • paroxetine depression
  • lower blood sugar
  • effective weight loss program
  • diuretic pills
  • canada med store
  • norvasc prescription
  • fluconazole 150mg
  • order drugs without a prescription
  • drugs used to aid sleep
  • description of soma
  • health bone disorder
  • face wrinkles
  • buy tadalafil cialis
  • cheap drugs
  • muscle spasm relief
  • how to boost immune system
  • what is premature ejaculation
  • echinacea dosage
  • clomid and fertility
  • diabetes type 2
  • free weight loss supplements
  • anxiety medication side effects
  • stop pain
  • generic amoxicillin
  • dog medication discount
  • remedies for bone loss
  • signs of high blood pressure
  • heart attack prevention
  • generic name viagra
  • buy birth control pills
  • erectile dysfunction treatments
  • pills for anxiety
  • zantac prevacid
  • online diet drugs
  • body building info
  • water pills side effects
  • safe diet pill
  • natural remedies for constipation
  • cure bronchitis
  • new medicine for diabetes
  • what is a natural antibiotic
  • best weight loss solutions
  • how to buy viagra
  • prozac pharmacy
  • cialis cheap prices
  • online pain dr
  • lower back pain relief
  • better erection
  • treatment of diabetes
  • pain relief on line
  • dog infections
  • treatment for diabetes
  • heart rate treatments
  • overdose zolpidem
  • buy canadian drugs
  • free diet pills
  • weight loss pills
  • generic trileptal
  • buy vitamin a
  • h1n1 flu
  • blood pressure lower
  • neck muscle pain
  • buy medicine online
  • order vitamins online
  • diet suppliments
  • medication prices
  • treatment of high blood pressure
  • latest treatment for heart attack
  • acne care treatment
  • acai cleanse
  • smoke stop
  • reducing blood pressure
  • cures for lung cancer
  • hair care hair loss
  • gaining muscle mass
  • high blood pressure med
  • anabolic creatine
  • help for constipation
  • canada online pharmacy
  • treatment for gout
  • medicine for depression
  • online drug store
  • natural back pain relief
  • clonidine dosage
  • drugs heart rate
  • severe hair loss
  • chlamydia antibiotics
  • cure for aids
  • cheap 37 5 phentermine
  • atenolol 25mg
  • cheap pain medications
  • generic zyrtec
  • health products for men
  • dermatitis swelling
  • free weight loss products
  • cymbalta vs lexapro
  • ways to reduce high blood pressure
  • health information bone health general
  • high blood pressure cause
  • online drug
  • pharmacy information
  • treatment of type 1 diabetes
  • new antibiotic drug
  • online pain management
  • fat loss secrets
  • lowering cholesterol naturally
  • sleep disorders drugs
  • wholesale dog products
  • total health discount
  • prozac pharmacy online
  • pet cat care
  • treatment for menopause
  • generic viagra lowest price
  • anxiety medication side effects
  • colon cleanes
  • upper left abdominal pain
  • high blood pressure medical treatment
  • joint pain cure
  • order vermox tablets
  • sildenafil online
  • bone health risk
  • hair loss treatment prices
  • treatment for menopause
  • dogs mouth antibiotic
  • atarax generic
  • weight loss systems
  • treatment of acne
  • anxiety help
  • medicine paxil
  • online pain medicine
  • prostate cancer cures
  • color of viagra
  • where to order soma
  • betablockers
  • ways to lower high blood pressure
  • prednisone buy
  • stomach pains
  • wholesale dog products
  • health med online
  • diet pill rx
  • treatment of bph
  • pain in right side
  • information on viagra
  • sleeping problems
  • anti allergic drug
  • online discount pharmacy
  • buy avodart
  • alcoholism pill
  • health bone disorder
  • weight loss support group online
  • medication for anxiety
  • build muscle strength
  • weight loss tip
  • buy cialis delived next day
  • buy body building supplement
  • order perscription drugs online
  • msm information
  • viagra type drugs
  • propecia without prescription
  • hypertension
  • prozac on line
  • levitra discount presciptions
  • aldactone medication
  • list of cancer treating drugs
  • otc sleep aids
  • buy now cialis
  • zoloft discount